Tuesday, February 16, 2010

Save Journalism, Save the World

Charlie Beckett's thought provoking statements in the introduction and first chapter of his book, Super Media, Saving Journalism So It Can Save the World, bring up many questions that I haven't even thought of.  His introduction is jam packed with brilliant ideas that pave the way for a great book. 

I like how he says that he doesn't pretend to be objective, but instead he aims to be fair, accurate, and thorough.  The changes that Beckett says are taking place in journalism, offer an immense opportunity for growth and what he believes is a whole new type of journalism.  Networked Journalism is a new way of practicing journalism where there isn't just the journalist working for the news outlet.  Now there are citizen journalists, interactivity, blogging, microblogging, and social networking that are all an indispensable part of the production and distribution of news.

I love the link Beckett has taken from Professor Roger Silverstone who compares journalism to the environment.  Journalism is facing its own kind of global warming.  Beckett estimates that we have "five years - perhaps ten - to save journalism so that journalism can save the world."  What would a world without journalism look like?


How will it be easier to deal with issues going on in the world with this "cosmopolitan, interactive 'audience'"?


Do you think the lack of diversity in journalism is because of the media corporations telling people what they can and cannot write about? Or do you think it is because of something else?  With blogging will we or have we begun to see diversity? And if so has the diversity been publicized?

On page 21 Beckett talks about the loss of the audience in mainstream news media.  The way I see it, because broadband is not being reached to everyone, we will still not reach all audiences online and some that may have gotten their news on television will not be able to go online.  How can we make up for that? Or how can that gap be fixed?


Here is an article that talks about how "computer nerds" could save journalism.  It was published in Time magazine online a few months ago. 

Thursday, February 4, 2010

Midterm

Networked Journalism
Midterm Exam
February 4, 2010

Please answer the following questions as clearly, concisely and thoughtfully as you can. Use examples whenever possible. And proof read your work. Email me your answers by 5pm February 15, 2010. If I don't respond by 11pm email it again. Please paste your answers into the body of the email and make the subject "midterm." Thanks.

PART 1: Provide short answers (4-8 sentences) for the following questions.

1. What is the difference between bias and framing according to Schudson?

2. Who are the people formerly known as the audience and why are they called that?

3. What are some of the constraints the marketplace imposes on journalism?

4. What is Twitter and how do journalists use it?

5. What is are APIs and how are they changing journalism?


PART 2: Please write a 2-3 page double-spaced essay for each of the following 2 questions and draw on and cite material we have read and/or watched for class.

1. Write an essay on the framing of this news story. Begin by discussing what is a news frame and, according to the readings, what accounts for different frames. Then analyze the story in terms of its frame. Pay attention to visuals, sources, information included and excluded, themes, language, outlet that it appeared in, larger environment within which the media exists, and target readership.

2. Write an essay describing the changing taking place in journalism with the emergence multi- or rich- media formats and new media tools such as APIs, blogs, twitter and other social networking platforms. What are the major differences in journalism today compared to journalism 20 years ago in terms of how stories are reported and told and the role of the public in the news media environment. Please use specific news stories to illustrate in your answer.

Response for February 4th

In the article Blogger vs. Journalism Jay Rosen brings up significant points in the field of journalism over the roles that both bloggers and professional journalists play in the press. I use the term professional journalists because I (like Rosen) believe that bloggers are also a type of journalist except they typically don’t get paid to do their job.

In the article Rosen argues that the debate over bloggers and journalists has shift from and “us vs. them” game to and “us vs. how do we include them” game. Rosen lays out some pretty strong arguments for how big media and bloggers can incorporate into each other and still find a satisfy and their individual niches of serving the public just in different ways. In an article written by Mark Glaser he argues that the lines between blogger and journalist are being blurred even more. He states that blog companies are hiring seasoned reporters in order to gain more credibility and trust and that Rosen talked about in his article. Also seasoned journalists of major newspapers have started blogging as a way of getting their stories and “voice” out there.

Glaser goes on to argue that the line between journalist and blogger has been blurring since 2002. Similar to the state Rosen made in his article that blogs and traditional journalism have been intersecting every since 2001 and the terrorist attacks. The claim that I would like to make is that journalism and bloggers are still in debate. While this blurring of the lines has occurred I still don’t believe that major news organizations have truly embraced the blog for what it is. I believe they see it as another market to be tapped not a parallel market that will in some ways make their jobs easier and in other ways challenge them to keep up.

What do you think?

Is the battle between Journalists and Blogger over? Or are the battle lines just shifting?

Is main stream media truly starting to embrace the world of blogging or is it viewing it as another market to be tapped?


The Blogosphere: Equality for All?

Power Law can more simply be explained through the common phrase the 80/20 Rule. The 80/20 Rule was named after the Italian economist Vilfredo Pareto who noticed that 80% of income in Italy was received by 20% of the Italian population. The assumption is that most of the results in any situation are determined by a small number of causes.

Clay Shirky’s article, Power Laws, Weblogs, and Inequality, applies the power law to the world of blogging. He writes about the rise of an “A-List,” a small group of bloggers who constitute a majority of the traffic in the blogosphere. Shirky discovers that the online world, more specifically the blogosphere, is not filled with freedom and equality after all.

Shirky explains, “Diversity plus freedom of choice creates inequality, and the greater the diversity, the more extreme the inequality.”

He goes on to clarify explaining that in particular systems where most people are free to choose between a multitude of options, there is a small group, in this case the “A-list,” that will receive an inordinate amount of traffic.

Power law distributions are more likely to arise in social systems where large amounts of people express their preferences among several options. Shirky explains that, “as the number of options rise, the curve becomes more extreme.” So basically as the blogosphere gets bigger the percentage of “A-listers” as a proportion to total bloggers, gets smaller.

In ranking the likeness of a particular blog, one would assume that they were making the decision on their own. Unbeknownst to them, their freedom of choice is not always free or rather, they do not realize that they are not making a decision on their own. A small number of blogs that have been chosen (as in “liked”) in the past are more likely to be chosen in the future. From this system Shirky describes the emergence of a “preference premium.” So future users will not be selecting blogs at random but by preference premium, which has been built up by all of the past users.

There still is no answer as to why one blog may be preferred over another. Shirky comments that it could be a “preference for quality…a preference for marketing” or a preference based on what one’s friends like. It is just important to not that for whatever reason “diverse and free systems” can create power law distributions.

Shirky poses the question “Is the inequality fair?” He is referring to the inequality in the blogosphere. He explains that there are four things that indicate that the current inequality is primarily fair:

1) The freedom in the blogosphere.
2) Blogging is a daily activity; if a blogger stopped writing, his or her blog would just disappear.
3) The “stars exist because of the preference of hundreds of others pointing to them.”
4) There is no real A-list because there is no discontinuity.

By relying on power law distribution, Shriky doubts that there are bloggers that are as talented and deserving as the current A-list who are simply not getting any traffic. Even though the blogosphere is expanding to see more readers and writers, Shriky believes that they will just add to the traffic of the current A-listers. As the online world gets bigger, it will get harder and harder for someone to prove themselves in the blogosphere. This gap will just keep growing and growing.



Questions

The idea of the power law seems to be fixed in mathematics, but do you really believe that all of the great blogs have already been discovered?

In your opinion, is the inequality of the blogosphere fair? What do you think about the idea of a free but unequal market?

In hopes that broadband can be extended to the masses, what do you think will happen to the weblog and this online marketplace of ideas?

Shirky writes this whole article to explain what the A-list is. He goes on to show how it exists with the idea of power law, but then when he lists his four reasons as to why the current inequality is fair, he says that there really is no A-list because there is no discontinuity. What is this contradiction all about? What does he mean by this?


To check out more of Clay Shirky’s writing, click here.
Response for February 4

In response to Alex's post on the 80/20 rule, I have to ask myself a few questions. First of all, Shirky states he believes that some blogs are not recognized the way they should be. However, one of the main reasons this may be true is that the key words do not match on the search engine? That could be a fatal flaw in the blogger. However, if the blogger doesn't find away to get attention form a search engine then it may not be the sharpest blog to begin with. Additionally, writing clarity and organization add to the readership. If I stumble across a poorly written blog, chances are I am not going to add it to my bookmarks.
Consistency and creativity are key features to keep an active blog readership. Many factors go into the maintenance of an effective blog. Take for example, the "beppegrillo" blog that has received so much attention in Italy and globally. There are daily posts, videos, and pictures to keep the audience coming back for more.

Shirky talks of a "preference premium," where a select few blogs gain more attention, overshadowing many other blogs. Do you think this premium is well deserved? Or are other equally as good blogs being overshadowed due to it?
One last question, if high quality blogs are overshadowed by these "preference premium" blogs, then how can the public find these blogs and recognize them as high quality as well?

On a related note, while researching for my paper prospectus I stumbled across a great website that breaks down some of the terminology and technical issues relating to how to "survive and thrive" as a journalist in today's world. Definitely worth checking out! It is called "Journalism 2.0".

Tuesday, February 2, 2010

A New Watchdog: Open Source and Participatory Journalism

We Media Introduction by Dale Peskin

Participatory Journalism= The act of a citizen, or group of citizens, playing an active role in the process of collecting, reporting, analyzing, and disseminating news and information. The intent of this participation is to provide independent, reliable, accurate, wide-ranging, and relevant information that a democracy requires.It is a bottom-up phenomenon that is the result of many simultaneous, distributed conversations.

Time to Get Off the Bus by Zack Exley

Off the Bus Website -click around

Off the Bus is a citizen journalism project, co-published by Arianna Huffington and Jay Rosen, to help “radically improve” the coverage of the 2008 presidential election by empowering new kinds of people to write a new kind of news.

I. Gaps mainstream media can’t reach

A. Inaccuracies around reporting the “new” aspects of campaigning that involve the Internet, technology, new kinds of voter data and targeting practices, new kinds of field organizing

B. Lack of time and resources

C. Poor positioning: only chasing candidates and campaign spokespeople

II. Embraces the concept of “You”=average person

A. Understand the new rules of the presidential campaigns

B. Support one, both, or neither party

C. Volunteer by making phone calls, knocking on doors, donating money, and using the internet to connect with others

III. Unlike mainstream media, this will give a more complete and accurate picture of American politics

A. A whole new approach, including thousands of opinions, coverage from many angles (Healthcare example: analyzing from policy experts, health care workers and patients’ viewpoints)

B. Not restrictive writing like mainstream media’s “master narrative” because they are not restricted to the professionalism rules, ethics and editor mechanics like the mainstream media.

C. Thousands of people from “you” group will investigate how campaigns are operating in individual communities which will keep the nation connected. Example: June 9th Obama campaign launched an organized field operation called “Walk for Change.” 10,000 people gathered at more than 1,000 events (mostly organized by volunteers) to door-knock Democratic primary voters. This event didn’t happen on “the bus”-meaning it was not a typical, routine organized campaigning event (by way of means other than the internet) mainstream news barely covered it.

Bloggers vs. Journalists is Over by Jay Rosen

The everlasting argument of bloggers vs. journalists has ended. The question is not whether blogs can be journalism or if bloggers are journalists, but rather to find a deep pattern of which the two are a part.

I. Extension of “the press” to the people that were traditionally and once formerly known as the public

A. Press has shifted social location from media to include open-source media and participatory journalism (in the hands of the public) because of the Web and blogs.

II. Not Sovereign- professional journalism no longer has total control over the territory it once patrolled. This doesn’t mean it will disappear, it just means its influence is no longer singular.

A. There are more centers of power and influence.

B. Journalism is no longer a “gatekeeper” of the news: it has been challenged by technology, competition and its audience

C. Tools that make this shift possible: easy Web publishing tools, always-on connections, mobile devices.

D. The audience has now become an active participant of creating and disseminating news and information.

III. “The paper doesn’t have a voice”

A. Mainstream big media lacks a voice. There is no personal connection.

B. Objectivity is part of this problem. Once an ethical touchstone for journalism, objectivity now represents a control over the message and producing a rigid story that excludes voices beyond the narrowly conventional.

C. Natural disasters (earthquake and tsunamis in South Asia and their aftermath) represent the tipping point in citizen journalism because there is more of human connection among readers and writers, a feeling of empathy, not just stark reporting.

IV. The rise of blogs does NOT equal the death of professional journalism

A. Internet is turning into a symbiotic ecosystem=different parts feed off each other and t he whole thing grows

B. Participatory media and journalism are different but online they exist in a shared realm

C. Both bring different strengths to the table and both benefit

Ending Key Points:

1. Blogs are “little First Amendment machines.”

2. Trust/reputational capital is the number one asset of the news organization. This is accomplished by professional standards being met which will maintain the brand. Blogs too require trust, but they have to build their reputations from the ground up. If you blog responsibly, you will build a reputation as a trusted news source. To gain this trust, they must focus on uses and have to be in dialogue with other readers and bloggers.

3. Pro-Ams are amateurs who work to professional standards. They are knowledgeable, educated, committed and networked by technology. They are new sources of authority and new kinds of organizations. (Citizen Journalists)

4. News as a conversation will create greater credibility and trust among journalists and the audience.

Strengths of citizen journalism: Vividness, mass volume, and wide availability of first person accounts on news and events. Shared via blogs, text messages, and videos on the Internet.

Weakness of citizen journalism: Lack of shape, structure and meaning of the story.Traditional media has disciplines such as space, deadlines, headline, intro, cohesive story in a specific structure (like inverted pyramid), and layout give the stories priority, meaning and understanding to make better sense of the world.

“The point of innovation in media is to expand, not simply to displace, the voices that existed before,” blogger and Web philosopher Mitch Ratcliffe.


YouTube Video "Behind the Citizen Journalism Revolution"href="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6xse5aKtJQg">


Crowd Sourced Journalism
I found this article online explaining Assignment Zero, an experimental project in Pro-Am Journalism. However, I think this article’s definition of Pro-Am is much different than Rosen’s. Here, the concepts of Pro (that of professional journalists) and amateurs (citizen journalists) are combined to work together in a “win-win situation,” claims the author where amateurs write and report and journalists edit. What do you think? Are the negatives of citizen journalism that are mentioned in this article valid and/or relevant? Will this solve the “problem” or bridge the gap between journalists and bloggers?


Discussion Questions:

1. Are there additional “tipping points” other than natural disasters that can create an upsurge of participatory reporting/journalism?

2. Can professional journalism transform to have more of a voice? How? Will it benefit from the change?

3. How does a writer “blog responsibly” in order to gain readers’ trust?

4. Citizen journalism’s weakness is said to be that blogs lack shape, structure and meaning as opposed to traditional journalism’s rigid structure and construction of understanding. Is this truly a weakness? Why or why not?

5. Do citizen journalists play the role of “watchdog?” Who are they watching: professional journalists, the sources of news, or both?

projects referenced by Josh

Everyblock

Spot.Us

Thirst in the Mojave

Water Life

Black Saturday