Tuesday, January 26, 2010

We're going on a field trip Thursday...

Instead of meeting in Sturm, we're going to attend this panel on broadband access at Denver Open Media on Thursday. There is a panel from 2:30-3 on the development of broadband access projects supported by the Federal Government stimulus plan.
So we'll meet at the DOM studio--700 Kalamath/7th by 2:30. We'll talk details in class.

You are Invited to a Panel and Discussion Sponsored by Open Media
Foundation, Colorado Common Cause, and the Media and Democracy
Coalition:

“Bringing Universal Broadband to Colorado”
Thursday, January 28, 2010, 1-3 p.m.
The Studios of Denver Open Media, Denver, CO


Forty years after the invention of the Internet in the United States,
many regions of our country do not have access to affordable,
accessible broadband Internet. What was once a luxury service is more
and more indispensable to our lives – like a utility, like electricity
or water.

Please come to hear about plans to assure lower rates and fast service
for all Coloradans, and hear from the community organizations that are
working to make this vision happen through the federal broadband
programs.


Presenters:

Denise Atkinson-Shorey, Centennial Board of Cooperative Educational Services
Ken Fellman, President of the National Association of
Telecommunications Officers and Advisors
John Conley, Office of the Governor’s Office of Technology
Tony Shawcross, Executive Director of the Open Media Foundation
(more to be added)


PLEASE RSVP TO hmiller@media-democracy.net or call (215) 888-8036

Location: The studios of Denver Open Media
700 Kalamath Street
Denver, CO 80204

Panels will also be live on Channel 56 and rebroadcast on 57 and 219
(digital tier). For more information, contact Hannah Miller at
215-888-8036 or email hmiller@media-democracy.net.
Open Media Foundation: www.openmediafoundation.org

Cosponsored by the Media and Democracy Coalition
www.media-democracy.net

Monday, January 25, 2010

1991 v. Today

Tomgram

Maybe it is the cynic in me, but when I read the third paragraph quote from John Nichols, "On the eve of his recent sojourn in Europe, President Bush had an unpleasant run-in with a species of creature he had not previously encountered often: a journalist.” I started laughing. While I do not have any beef with GW Bush the man, I am about as opposed to his policies as one can be. Furthermore, I don’t have anything against conservatives in general, but reading about his administrations suppression of the media disgusted me. But hearing how the media responded to being kicked around without doing anything disgusted me more. It made me think of a dog cowering in front of an abusive owner in the hope of receiving a few scraps of rotten food.

What I feel even more than disgust is fear. The fact that, as supported by Andrew’s articles, major PR firms can leverage our elected officials and news media to get their way is very disturbing to me. What scares me even more is that we elected, twice, a man who invades countries because God told him to. Not that I have anything against God fearing Americans… I just don’t feel that one incapable of basic articulation and fact-based judgment should be President of the United States.

I read one article related to this topic from the Washington Post. It deals with a 20 million dollar contract put out in 2006 in an effort to get some positive PR from Iraq. The argument is that media was unfair in its coverage and only put out negative things from Iraq. I’ll leave it for you to consider.

Is it ethical for the government to pay PR firms to try and paint a positive picture to retain support? Or should their actions speak for themselves?

And now... my thoughts on some of Andrews questions (warning: I got a little preachy here)

Controlled News Coverage and Its Impact on the Public

-Should the public matter more in the creation of news? Should there even be creation of news in the first place? Rather than an objective telling of the facts, a great deal of what was reported as “news” in the first gulf war, especially that surrounding public support for the war, was, if not entirely fabricated, spun to the max. I do think that the public should hold more sway over what does and does not get reported. That said, it is only because there is a marketplace for smut that the issue of creationism in the news even comes to the fore. If the public could diverge its attention away from the gossipy world of “breaking news” (especially about young boys in balloons) and immerse itself in the work of good investigative journalism and fact-based reporting, the news media institution itself would have to shift its focus.

-How do the spiral of silence and rally around the flag theories interact? What do they create? Because of media reach in today’s society, I think it has a tremendous impact on what is perceived as popular and important. The rally theory supports my view that it is standard in times of war for citizens of a given country to inhale a deep breath of nationalism and exhale patriotism; the news media is not excluded from this movement to support for ones leaders. The desire to be included in a community is part of human nature. Therefore, if the majority supports one opinion, those who like to consider themselves part of the majority group will join them. Individuals who do not join, and consider their opinion to be unpopular will often remain silent, and the pattern will repeat, thus the spiral of silence. This polarization of full support or dead silence allows for the creation of an artificial power. The majority group can push its agenda because most who hold opposing views stay silent.

-What difference does new media make with regards to war? An individual’s ability to fact-check online and post questions is a key difference. Additionally, the ability of citizens in a war zone to report the goings on creates a new kind of accountability. Just recently, when German soldiers blew up a gas tanker that had been stolen in Afghanistan, people immediately began taking pictures with phones and posting them online. At first, Germany said that they had killed mainly militants, but the pictures told a different tale.

PR in the First Gulf War

Have PR firms and politicians managed to take hold of news and information? Successfully? I think PR has taken control of the news and the politicians. I am less inclined to think that all of our elected officials are lobbyists. The comprehensiveness with which PR firms built support for Desert Storm is staggering and confirms the strength of their hold on the media. I found the bit about t-shirt very interesting in this article. As a student, I do not tend to worry about who may be behind my free clothing.

Tomgram

-Have politicians found an effective way to control the press's check on government power? By keeping their hands tied, and their eyes covered, the government has done a tremendous job of curbing the press’ ability to hold them accountable. I do not think that it would take very much for the press to break their restraints and do some good reporting. Furthermore, I think that the Obama administration’s move toward more transparency will allow the press to ask more of the hard questions that were forbidden during the Bush reign.

-How did acceptance of the Bush doctrine lead to a problem in the media? It led to a loss of quality journalism. The media readily reported facts from the Bush White House without doing even simple fact-checking work. They got lazy and allowed themselves to be pushed around. The fear that doing good journalism would get them excluded led many papers to settle for mediocrity and inaccurate information.

1991 Gulf War v. Iraq War (Andrew Evans)

Gulf War: Controlled News Coverage and Its Impact on the Public ***please read***

I. Public Opinion
-The public opposed the Gulf War as late as the day it started.
-This image was not shown by the news outlets.
-Less than one percent of news outlets claimed there was opposition to the war (257)
-After the war started debate ceased and the nation supported the war

II. Press
-News Outlets framed the war positively
-did not report the opposition
-continuous coverage of war attached with "primed messages"
-characterized congressional dissent unfavorably (275)
*independent coverage= difficult as access was limited
*The Pentagon Achieved high media control
*stories during war were often changed to reflect message

III. Military control
-directed media message (271)
-technical jargon created confusion and influenced the press's message (278)

IV. Technology
-continuous coverage reiterate bias
-live coverage backed up message (272)

V. The Press and Theories
i. Rally around the Flag: present during the war
-supported Bush's policies rather than those of the Public
-The public changes its opinion based on the bias of the press. The more biased, the less/more favorable an opinion will be (262)
-need for strong support of the president lead to favorable opinion of the elites and of George H.W. Bush (262-263)
-people accepted the media and reverberated its message once the war started

ii.Spiral of Silence: pre-war with influence during the war
-public opinion is influenced by self-censorship and a limited number of messages in the media(263)
-media and individual= create opinion (263-264)
-with the media supporting a positive message and the individual supporting other ideas, the apparent gap between the majority and the individual widens (265)
*representation of a majority consensus acts as a gatekeeper: people create stereotyped worlds and the media forms them (266)

X. Questions
-Should the public matter more in the creation of news?
-How do the spiral of silence and rally around the flag theories interact? What do they create?
-Should the media find other routes for information?
-What opportunities did the media have to obtain unbiased information?
-What difference does new media make with regards to war?
-The authors suggest that such factors can play a role in creating opinion of the war. Was this true of the Iraq War or the Afghanistan war at the turn of this century?

X. PR in the First Gulf War ***please read***
i. control of politics
-PR firm Hill and Knowlton, contracted by the Kuwaiti government, lobbied to obtain politicians support
-directed their efforts at key Republicans, and notable Democrats
-chief of staff connected to Bush
-input of information at conference on Iraq's human rights
-Bush repeated story supplied with firm involved

ii. press
-Hill and Knowlton tried to direct public opinion through media
-created dozens of PR videos that were played by major media outlets
-during war military tried to control image
-released information and videos that toned down civilian casualties and played up reasons for attacking
*created the illusion of a clean war when over 100,000 civilians are killed

X. Questions
-Have PR firms and politicians managed to take hold of news and information successfully? How does this effect the press's check on government?
-Do the large media outlets exaggerate the effects of these politicians and PR firms.
-Do traditions allow for media to latch on and further fabricate an image?


X. Tomgram
I. Bush
-fundamentalist who relied on faith-based intelligence and truth
-disregarded medias "quest for truth"
-critical of media organizations that did not support his policies
-controlled access to information

II. press
-in time of crisis
-large media outlets supported Bushes views in a need for acceptance by administration
-only started to bring skepticism back from the margins after the Iraq war started to go badly

III. Effects
-press seen not as legitimate but for entertainment value
-hampered the medias check on government for a time

X.Questions
-Have politicians found an effective way to control the press's check on government power?
-How did acceptance of the Bush doctrine lead to a problem in the media?
-What other factors are involved in large media outlets current crisis?
-Thinking back to class discussions. Why were media outlets more effected in this war than the Gulf War? How did new media play a role in that demise?

Wednesday, January 20, 2010

News Turns from a Lecture to a Conversation and The People Formerly Known as the Audience

The title given to this week’s discussion is “Rethinking the Public.” I think that we’re not so much “rethinking” the public as we are including the public. Rosen refers to news changing from a lecture to a conversation, which means two-way communication, a back-and-forth between not only journalists and an audience, but now between members of the audience as well. A shift has occurred from a top-down, vertical hierarchy of delivering news, to a horizontal flow that encourages participation. People have always reacted, discussed and debated the news and its coverage, but did so in private realms between known acquaintances. Now, that discussion is available in a public, online forum.

In response to one of the discussion questions, I think neither the audience nor the media has more power. I think it is now shared. Rosen calls it a “shift in power.” He relates to two comments that describes power moving away from the “centroids,” large, media outlets toward the individuals who are considered to be on the edge. These "edglings," or the public, share and participate through open technology. I personally don’t think one group or another has control, that control is moving, or even that it’s shifting. I think it is expanding to encompass all, the entire world community, including media giants, journalists and ordinary citizens alike. News and its power is no longer exclusive, like Rosen writes, but inclusive. The things that the news industry has lost, so to speak, from this evolution is its exclusiveness, monopoly, and primary decisiveness in choosing and publishing the news. The public doesn’t wish to control the media; they just want to be an active part of it, by “taking part, debating, creating, communicating and sharing.”

Both Rosen and another article I found mention that some of the fears of journalists and news organizations is that blogs will take over the news industry, drive it out of business and that journalism isn’t considered journalism if it doesn’t undergo an editorial process. The article I found said that neither is the case, nor will it ever be. The author of the article, J.D. Lasica explains that most viewers will get their “fix” from traditional news stories and that blogging complements the original coverage in more depth, with more analysis, alternative perspectives, and sometimes first person accounts (p. 73). It used to be that once news was printed, it was finished. This is no longer true, thanks to the creation of an active audience through blogs and threads on news articles allowing for comments online. The role of the press now is to encourage the conversation by prompting it with a particular story.

Another discussion question asks if journalists should feel threatened by the emergence of bloggers. The answer is no. Lasica also addresses something that was mentioned in one of Rosen’s blogs which is competing for readers’ eyeballs. Instead, journalism and blogging, as mentioned before, complement and play off each other and intersect. Blogging has expanded journalism’s role by making it more accessible and interactive. I think blogging makes journalism richer because news is constantly being updated and evolving through dialogue and it reaches a wider audience.

I think things have just evolved, not simply changed. Mentioned in the leader's blog, the publisher-audience relationship still remains, it is just now a loop, not a pipe. I think this change should be welcomed, in order to ensure a sense of community involvement. By encouraging this level of shared and active participation, I feel like it opens more opportunities for the public to be informed, especially when they can discuss, question, and learn about what most interests them, not what news media outlets think is important or interesting.

Questions:
1) What is the role of a blogger? What should it be?
2) What does it mean to be a member of the audience? Can there still be an audience even though they now are sharing and publishing their ideas?
3) Lecture is to audience as conversation is to __________?

Top Ten Ideas of ’04: News Turns From a Lecture To A Conversation

Themes

· News begins once its printed.

o Used to be that the news was finished once it was printed.

o New Journalism has feedback from audience that advances the story.

· Conversational vs Authority.

o Blogs put pressure on journalists because of the demand for news to be “conversational”.

o Audience’s demand for news to become more conversational is a result from a “shift in power”.

· Shift in Power.

o Puts more tools, choices, and media capacity in the hands of the people formerly known as the audience.

· Consumers use the internet to become active participants in the exchange of news and ideas.

· Bloggers.

o Post eyewitness accounts and photos about news events

o Help newspapers get more local in their coverage.

o Tell big media what the people are thinking.

Questions

1) Should journalists feel threatened because of the emergence of blogging?

2) How should big media adapt to the ongoing feedback from new media?

3) Aside from the writing format, what are some distinctive differences between bloggers and journalists?

The People Formerly Known As The Audience

Themes

· Blogging, Podcasting, Television, which was all once controlled by Big Media, has shifted partially to the audience’s control.

o Blogs extend freedom of the press to a wider audience.

o Podcasting lets people here each other’s opinions.

o The web lets people telecast their own video’s.

· Jeff Jarvis- If media control is given to the public they will use it, if it is not given to them then the big media will loose control.

· Tom Curley- users decide what point of their engagement will be in the new media what application, what device, what time, what place.

· Audiences want media to be better than it is, so they broadcast and publish independent work themselves.

· Dave Winer- Once control is given to the audience, they will never give it back.

· New Media has made the public more real, able and less predictable.

· We are each other’s audience.

o Communication between citizen-to-citizen (horizontal flow), is as real and consequential as the hierarchy of power (vertical flow).

o Publisher-Audience relationship remains, but it is a loop, not a pipe.

Questions

1) Who is more in power, the audience or media?

2) How does the big media try to mediate the audiences crave for power?

3) What are active audiences?

4) Do weblogs restore trust back into the media?

Tuesday, January 19, 2010

Andrew Evans Response Questions

I. Freedom of Expression

The zone for freedom of expression in America is much more complicated than Schudson hints at and has developed to include protection of speach within certain large perameters. The first amendment was originally interpreted in a restrictive manner. Cases ruled along the lines of William Blackstone's idea that speech should be promoted as long as it does not interfere with government activities, for which everyone was held accountable. This meant that the government and courts, while not resorting to the outright denial of printing rights, could take extensive action against the press. Eventually, the courts began to change their opinion of the first amendment and thus the law. The bad tendency test, which relied on the ability of speech to create harm, was proceeded by the clear and present danger test. Subsequent cases began to accept such developments. Due to these developments, freedom of expression means many different things. Under the tests and even cases that will need to be retried from previous interpretations, freedom is greatest among adults and dissipates with relation to age and situation, say government employment and media. Prisoners have the least rights. In the interest of the media, they are allotted nearly the same rights as government employees. Which means that media can print as long as it does not harm others, make false accusations, or commit various other acts such as violating statutory law. The supreme court has dealt with media extensively. The zone for freedom of expression is constantly changing and for media the current zone includes some limitations, many reasonable.

Against this backdrop, which developed with the development of the press and continues to do so, more freedom of expression basically means that anything that could potentially hinder the ability of the state to govern or even harm others. This would mean granting the media the ability to keep sources secret and operate with almost complete freedom. While sensationalism is great, harming others can be dangerous. For media and government relations, the freedom of expression currently granted has posed a problem. The Plame investigation has forced the government to tighten its control on information. Granting more freedom may jeopardize many even more. More freedom of expression would mean reducing limitations that allow government to continue unhindered and could greatly damage members of society.

II. Fair or Free

The idea that media can be fair or free relies on a spectrum created by either printing beliefs in a biased manner or accepting both sides and printing information that pertains to both. Either the journalist prints what they want or compromises and gives adequate treatment to both sides.

III. Form
Form is the style used to write a news report, either in the hard news style or feature format. It is the way in which the story is told. This comes in several different formats can be mixed but have, as Schudson mentions, authorized the journalist as an expert explaining which facts are most important (Schudson, 185). While many journalists do not see themselves as experts, they must be knowledgeable about what they are describing due to the need to present fact, leading to the connection between sources and experts.

IV. Culture
Cultural anamolies, events, people, or anything against the cut and dry idea of society, are present in the news. The relation between the widely held belief that Americans are too litigious and an anti-tort sentiment stemming from the idea that Americans are hard working individuals is present within the media. The Plaintiffs are often presented as trying to bilk defendants out of money. What Schudson claims is present with homosexuality is present with tort cases as well. Cultural anamolies do exist.

Beyond anamolies, the media has remained incorrectly silent during times of security, danger, and tragedy. It is my opinion that the media needs to be active. Times such as these see great government activity that takes away freedom in the sake of security. After September 11, the media stood by and watched as the patriot act was enacted and advocated for the war in Iraq. The opportunity was present to criticize the activities. As long as they do not interfere with legitimate efforts, they should do so. These times deserve media attention since journalists are willing and capable of criticizing the government.

V. News, Emotion, and the Attention Span

Humans definitely develop an emotional attachment to news. Schudson remarks that the personality, voice and looks of the local anchor mattered most in television news (Schudson, 172). This meant that an emotional connection was made to the person. Researchers note that not only can newspapers connect with individuals but that even advertising can promote a response.

VI. Changing Papers

Catering to an audience of readers, extensive or mixed, means providing what is necessary and safe. In this instance providing relevant and substantive information is important. This allows for the time-filling function to exist while providing relevant information to the small number of individuals who need it. It also allows for the harm of sensationalism to be reduced. This type of news can change public opinion. While this can have obvious implications of society it also destroys the newspaper by advancing claims of cynicism. Newspapers can change to provide what readers want and reduce harm to themselves and society.